Evidence-based breastfeeding guidance
for families and the communities that support them

Trash the Pump and Dump

The Physician Guide to Breastfeeding, created by Dr. Katrina Mitchell, provides scientific lactation information for healthcare providers, breastfeeding moms, and communities.

A three part graphic. Graphic 1 shows two women talking. Graphic 2 shows a female surgeon. Graphic 3 shows a doctor giving advice to a woman with a newborn child.

Welcome, and thank you for visiting my website!  My name is Katrina Mitchell, and I am a breast surgeon, lactation consultant, and perinatal mental health provider in Santa Barbara, California.

I created the Physician Guide to Breastfeeding during the 2020 Covid pandemic, when I was inundated by parents and children suffering from a variety of breastfeeding challenges related to isolation and restricted contact with medical professionals.   “Lactastrophes”  — complications resulting from women being repeatedly given incorrect advice from unreliable sources and breastfeeding folklore — abounded.  

As a physician, I wanted to develop an evidence-based website free of commercial bias for parents, other healthcare providers, and lactation consultants.  My goal is to address common myths that have been perpetuated for decades in the lactation world, and illuminate the science. 

Many “traditional” recommendations offered to breastfeeding mothers are not only inaccurate, but harmful.   “N of 1” — a personal or professional experience limited by lack of generalizability to others — is often employed in lactation care.  This leads to confusion and contradictory advice.  Women can feel pressured to spend significant funds on breastfeeding products, and are exhausted by countless appointments with lactation or infant care “experts.”  Motherhood has become a big business, and the industry preys on women at a vulnerable time period in their lives.

Having operated on the breast for more than 15 years, I have a unique perspective on breast physiology and tissue anatomy.  This impacts the way I approach lactation challenges and resolve them, putting mother-infant dyads on a path to healthy physical and mental health development.

If you are caught in a miserable tailspin of any combination of 24/7 triple feeding, power pumping, washing bottles, timing feedings at the breast, using home scales, walking around naked trying to maximize “skin to skin”, tracking it all on an app, feeling overwhelmed by social media comparisons, pumping to keep your breast “empty to prevent mastitis,” coating your nipples with complicated concoctions, and hating breastfeeding and mothering in the process, you are in the right place now. 

The key is to SIMPLIFY and get back to basics. Whether it means helping a mom with too much milk become more comfortable, or supporting a mom with not enough milk, it’s necessary to establish a REASONABLE plan going forward.  When you confirm the correct diagnosis and provide straightforward treatment, everything gets better.  I receive daily emails from people thankful for simple advice, and one very descriptive patient gave me permission to share her story.

I encourage everyone reading this website to reach out to the Institute for the Advancement of Breastfeeding and Lactation Education (IABLE) for referral to knowledgeable breastfeeding medicine physicians and lactation providers throughout the world.